Why Simple Tools Build Better Pipers

Would you learn to drive in a Formula 1 car? Or master flight in a Boeing 787 Dreamliner? Of course not! These tools are for seasoned experts, not beginners. Yet, when it comes to learning bagpipes, many beginners are quick to embrace overly complex setups. 

Let’s talk about why simplicity matters - especially for beginners, or those trying to progress - and how simple tools can set you up for success.

Why Should We Aim For Simplicity?  

In a world where there are new gadgets, technologies and even AI now that can assist us to do plenty of things in our lives, why on Earth would we be telling you to go back to basics?

The answer is, simply, because simple tools work so well. They go back to core principles, remove distractions and let you focus on the fundamentals. Learning the bagpipes is a challenging enough pursuit without adding additional, unnecessary factors that can complicate things. When you’re starting out, a straightforward setup allows you to concentrate on essential skills, like steady breathing and blowing solid tone, instead of also having to consider extra variables when you're troubleshooting.

The Gadget Trap  

Gadgets promise a magical shortcut, but do they deliver? Not really. Instead of solving problems, they often introduce new ones - or worse, they mask challenges that every player needs to confront. 

For instance, a beginner might use a drying system to manage moisture in the bag. But this could prevent them from learning how to adjust their blowing technique to maintain consistent tone. The result? Gadgets delay the development of essential skills and create dependencies that are hard to break.

Take It Back to Basics

Starting with a simple setup forces you to engage with the instrument in its purest form. Stripping away unnecessary contraptions like tone enhancers, canisters, or complex reeds lets you face challenges head-on. Yes, you’ll make mistakes. But those mistakes are invaluable - they teach you the skills needed to become a confident, adaptable player.

Think of it this way: Would an artist rely on advanced software before mastering basic drawing skills? Would a swimmer use high-tech performance-enhancing gear before learning to float? No. Mastery begins with the fundamentals.

Practical Simplicity  

Ok, so you're sold on needing to go back to basics. So what does a simple bagpipe setup look like? A good place to start is with basic drone reeds and a bag (hide or hybrid, it's up to you). Avoid installing contraptions like desiccant materials or complicated water traps - I guarantee you that in most circumstances you don't need these. They might seem helpful but can distract you from learning proper technique - and some can actively make your sound worse.

Some tools are okay for practical reasons. For example, a moose valve or a humidity-controlling chanter cap won’t interfere with your learning process. But avoid anything that adds complexity or tries to "solve" problems you should be learning how to solve for yourself.

The Role of Gadgets  

Now this may all make me sound like I'm completely anti gadget and anti technology. That's absolutely, 100% not true. Gadgets aren’t inherently bad - they just need to be used at the right time. Advanced players with solid fundamentals often benefit from tools like moisture control systems to maintain their stability during long performances. I have one in my solo set-up right now for that very reason. But I'm a highly experienced, professional player who knows exactly what I'm doing, and I'm using that tool for a very specific purpose. 

Once you’ve mastered the basics, you’ll know when - and more importantly, if - you need to add complexity. By then, you’ll have the skills to manage any downsides those tools might bring too.

The Path to Mastery  

Learning the bagpipes isn’t about shortcuts. It’s about embracing the process. When you simplify your setup, you give yourself the space to truly understand your instrument. You’ll build confidence, develop your ear, and refine your technique, all without relying on crutches.

As you progress, you’ll gain the freedom to adapt to any setup. That’s the ultimate goal: creative and technical freedom with your instrument.

So before you pile on the gadgets, ask yourself: Is this tool helping me grow, or is it a shortcut that’s slowing me down? The best tools are the simplest ones. They let you focus on what matters most: the music. Keep it simple, stay committed, and watch your skills soar.

Check out this week's podcast (link below) as we discuss why playing with "simple tools" is so important when you're working towards mastering the bagpipes.